Commanders make colossal gamble by trading Jahan Dotson to division rival

This was an absolute bombshell out of nowhere.

The Washington Commanders gave up on wide receiver Jahan Dotson after another indifferent training camp. That wasn't entirely surprising when one considers Dan Quinn's comments about the WR2 battle. The shocking part? Trading him to a division rival.

Adam Peters struck a deal with the Philadelphia Eagles for Dotson. The Commanders get a third-round selection and two seventh-rounders in return, also giving a fifth-rounder as well as the pass-catcher. This caused a significant stir among the fanbase and represents a sad end to the former Penn State star's time with the franchise.

Dotson arrived as the No. 16 overall selection in the 2022 NFL Draft with ambitions to become a legitimate No. 2 opposite Terry McLaurin. He's barely cracked 500 receiving yards in each of his first two seasons and will now look to galvanize his career elsewhere, doing battle against the Commanders along the way.

The new regime didn't think Dotson would ever reach his pre-draft billing, which is fine. They also need additional capital to help with Peters' vast rebuilding. After all, this is a long-term growth plan.

Commanders trading Jahan Dotson to the Eagles is a colossal gamble

With all that being said, this represents a colossal gamble.

Howie Roseman is a shrewd general manager with a reputation for picking up players down on their luck and turning them around. If the same happens with Dotson, the Commanders will be paying a heavy price for years to come. This is also the second time Peters has done business with the Eagles this offseason, allowing them to move up for gifted defensive back Cooper DeJean in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Peters doesn't care about division rivalry. He'll accept the best offer no matter what. That's the way the respected front-office leader is approaching his time at the helm for good or bad. But it's going to sting if Dotson finally starts to fulfill his potential on a team Washington plays twice a year.

The Commanders feel like they have enough. However, the prospect of further reinforcements arriving off the waiver wire cannot be dismissed either.

Olamide Zaccheaus has drawn rave reviews from the coaching staff this offseason and could be the primary beneficiary. Washington is also immensely high on rookie third-rounder Luke McCaffrey - a man taken with the pick acquired from the Chase Young trade. Dyami Brown's blossoming vertical connection with quarterback Jayden Daniels is something else that could have led Peters down this path.

Some fans hadn't given up on Dotson despite his failure to break out within Eric Bieniemy's pass-happy scheme. The talent is there, but something was missing with the player in D.C. Peters deemed him not only expendable but someone he was willing to give to one of his primary competitors. That's a monumental call to make heading into Year 1 of his tenure.

Dotson will have extra motivation to prove Peters and the Commanders wrong. He joins a wideout room already consisting of A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith, making one-on-one opportunities plentiful. If the receiver doesn't excel in Philadelphia, he never will.

That's a risk Peters is willing to take, even if the immediate criticism wasn't hard to find. But make no mistake, this is the first jaw-dropping move that didn't receive wholesale approval among the fanbase.

More Commanders news and analysis