Grading the latest five Commanders signings including Deatrich Wise Jr. deal

The Commanders continue to mold their roster during free agency.
Deatrich Wise Jr.
Deatrich Wise Jr. | Eric Canha-Imagn Images
3 of 3

Commanders re-signed Michael Deiter

Keeping continuity was important for Adam Peters based on his moves throughout the offseason. There were some departures, but most of his 28 free agents seem to be sticking around in some capacity.

Some were expected. But in Michael Deiter's case, his one-year deal to remain with the Washington Commanders came with surprise and almost disbelief among the fanbase.

Deiter joined the Commanders last season. He was expected to be a key backup capable of manning every position on the offensive line interior. That's the role he assumed, but the production was nowhere near the required standard when tasked with starting responsibilities.

The production notably dropped off whenever Deiter was in the lineup. His pass-blocking was lackluster and quarterback Jayden Daniels wasn't nearly as comfortable. There wasn't much to like about his run-blocking either, so most fans thought the veteran would be moved on with little fanfare attached.

Peters had a different idea. Deiter gets another shot in Washington, but a huge effort is needed to enhance his claims for a roster spot again in 2025.

  • Signing grade: D

Deiter's retention is just keeping someone around for the sake of it. His production last season didn't justify another deal. If Peters can find an upgrade, he shouldn't hesitate.

Commanders re-signed Noah Brown

Noah Brown's season may have ended prematurely in 2024, but the Commanders believe he's still got something to offer.

The wide receiver was a late arrival to the Commanders after being cut by the Houston Texans. Brown gradually emerged as the No. 2 receiving option opposite Terry McLaurin, earning the trust of Jayden Daniels and producing some high-caliber catches in key moments.

Brown also conjured one of the NFL's most memorable moments in 2024. His Hail Mary miracle catch against the Chicago Bears sent shockwaves through the league. It propelled the Commanders to a different stratosphere and plunged the NFC North club into complete disarray.

Unfortunately for Brown, his momentum came screeching to an abrupt halt with a serious internal injury against the Tennessee Titans. This one-year extension that could be worth up to $4.5 million suggests he's on the road to a full recovery.

This is a shrewd move from the Commanders. Brown is the bigger receiver Kliff Kingsbury needed to go alongside Terry McLaurin and Deebo Samuel Sr. Having someone capable of stretching the field is also going to open up space underneath, which is only going to help.

  • Signing grade: A

Brown is a good player who has the complete trust of head coach Dan Quinn. There's a good chance he can be influential in 2025 with a full offseason with the team.

More Commanders news and analysis

Schedule