Skip to main content

Jonathan Allen’s return could show Commanders they kept the wrong player

He'll have a big point to prove.
ByRyan McCafferty
Cincinnati Bengals defensive lineman Jonathan Allen
Cincinnati Bengals defensive lineman Jonathan Allen | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Washington Commanders are back home this week after an extended rest, but they'll face a tough battle against a Cincinnati Bengals team that's hotter than fish grease right now.

Joe Burrow is the leading NFL MVP candidate, and the Bengals have the league's best wide receiver tandem in Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. This Monday Night Football matchup will also feature a return to Washington for one player who spent eight productive seasons in D.C.

Jonathan Allen will be back in town. And he's having himself quite a season.

Jonathan Allen can make a statement against the team that released him

Allen was raised in Ashburn, Virginia. He went to Stone Bridge High School. He was drafted by Washington in the first round of the 2017 NFL Draft and made two Pro Bowls with his hometown team, accumulating 42 sacks and 60 tackles for loss in eight seasons.

He was consistently available and productive, playing at least 15 games in each of the six seasons between 2018 and 2023. He was a pro's pro and one of the team's most vocal leaders, both on the field and in the locker room.

But after Allen missed most of Washington's magical 2024 season with a torn pectoral, the team decided it was time to move on.

This, considering his continued high-level play and general manager Adam Peters' overpay for defensive lineman Javon Kinlaw as consolation, seems like a mistake.

And now, Allen has the chance to remind the Commanders what they're missing.

For years, the Bengals had two major weak spots. They had no offensive line and no defense, and they were wasting their all-world quarterback and receivers.

Commanders must be wary of Jonathan Allen in the prime-time spotlight

Both units have vastly improved in 2026.

The addition of Allen, along with his new linemate Dexter Lawrence II, has revived Cincinnati's pass rush. The 10-year pro has four sacks already this season, plus a forced fumble, and he's been a hit for the culture just as he was in Washington.

It always felt like Allen was the type of player who should have been a Commander for life, or at least until he had nothing left in the tank.

He was the Terry McLaurin of the defense. Allen and Daron Payne had inseparable chemistry as a dynamic duo on the interior defensive line, which began during their time together in college at Alabama.

Between the two of them, Payne was arguably the more expendable one. But the way their contracts lined up with Peters' timeline for success, Allen was allowed to pursue other opportunities.

He's made the most of this one, even if things didn't go quite as well during his one season with the Minnesota Vikings.

Now, Washington better hope he doesn't make them feel sorry.

Add us as a preferred source on Google