Washington Commanders fans were in collective delight after hearing that Sam Cosmi's 21-day return window was officially opened by the franchise. However, that won't be good news for everybody.
The stud right guard has been sorely missed since tearing his ACL. Cosmi has some additional markers to hit, but all signs point to his return to the starting lineup sooner rather than later. That's going to shift the offensive line's dynamic entirely, and one player could suffer more than most.
Nick Allegretti initially got the nod to replace Cosmi this season. It did not go well, and the coaching staff sent him to the bench in favor of Andrew Wylie after just two games. When the former Texas star gets the all-clear to participate on game days, he'll be pushed even further down the pecking order.
Commanders tipped to trade Nick Allegretti as Sam Cosmi's return looms
Gilberto Manzano from Sports Illustrated thought this could lead to Allegretti's inevitable exit before the 2025 trade deadline. The analyst tabbed the New England Patriots as a possible suitor, with a seventh-round pick touted as the compensation needed to finalize the deal.
"[Nick] Allegretti has gained starting experience during his time with the Chiefs and Commanders, having done so in 17 regular-season games, including two with Washington. He’s also a three-time Super Bowl champion. While trading for Allegretti isn’t going to change the Patriots’ fortunes, the move would provide a veteran voice and a player who can play either guard spot if coach Mike Vrabel decides to shake up a line that ranks 27th in sack percentage (9.5%) and 23rd in yards per carry (3.9)."Gilberto Manzano
Allegretti is a solid pro. He has the experience to slot into the unit if needed. That could be at the left guard spot if Chris Paul struggles, but the Commanders also have Brandon Coleman for that. He also happens to be younger and cheaper.
The former Illinois standout is set to count $7.17 million against Washington's salary cap in 2026, the final year of his deal. Cutting him saves $3.53 million next spring, but if Peters can get anything back in return, he should seriously consider the possibility.
This is not how Allegretti pictured his season going. But in all honesty, his performances since joining the Commanders in 2024 free agency just haven't met the required standard overall.
If Peters can find a willing suitor to take Allegretti off his hands, it represents the best possible solution for all parties. Whether this scenario comes to fruition or not is another matter.