Skip to main content

20 best Washington Commanders players who never made a Pro Bowl

The Pro Bowl was a prestigious honor once upon a time.
ByDean Jones
Former Washington Commanders quarterback Doug Williams
Former Washington Commanders quarterback Doug Williams | USA TODAY Sports

The Pro Bowl has lost its luster. Players stopped taking it seriously, and it descended into a farce with the Pro Bowl games before the NFL opted to scrap the festivities completely.

But not so long ago, it was viewed as a prestigious distinction.

The team now known as the Washington Commanders has had many Pro Bowlers throughout its illustrious history. Chris Hanburger holds the franchise record with nine Pro Bowl selections, closely followed by iconic names such as Charley Taylor, Darrell Green, Len Hauss, Ken Houston, and Sammy Baugh.

However, Washington's franchise history is full of talented players who never secured Pro Bowl honors despite their exceptional efforts. It was hard to choose, but here are the 20 best who never earned a Pro Bowl nod.

  1. The best Washington Commanders players who never made the Pro Bowl
  2. 20-15
  3. 15-10
  4. 10-5
  5. 5-1

The best Washington Commanders players who never made the Pro Bowl

20-15

20. Randy Thomas, OL

There is just no telling what Randy Thomas' career might have looked like if not for injuries. However, the imposing interior offensive lineman deserves a place on this list for his pure dominance before health problems immediately took hold.

Thomas joined Washington after a prolific spell with the New York Jets. He made his presence felt immediately, becoming a crushing run blocker for running back Clinton Portis and part of an offensive line that allowed only 19 sacks in 2006.

Unfortunately, two of Thomas' final three seasons in Washington were marred by injury. He did well to come back from a broken leg sustained against the Dallas Cowboys in 2005, and the last time anyone saw him on an NFL field was in 2009.

What might have been...

19. Pierre Garçon, WR

Pierre Garçon may not have the championships of several others on this list, but his time in Washington was full of memorable moments that deserved more recognition at the time.

Washington signed Garçon in 2012 free agency and immediately made a difference. The wide receiver played only five years with the club, but the numbers speak for themselves: 376 receptions for 4,549 receiving yards and 21 touchdowns before he joined the San Francisco 49ers.

Garçon actually led the league in receptions with 113 in 2013. This also broke iconic former Washington receiver Art Monk's longstanding single-season franchise record at the time, but it was not enough to earn Pro Bowl recognition.

That was egregious then and even more so now.

18. Kurt Gouveia, LB

Kurt Gouveia's place in franchise folklore is sealed. The ferocious linebacker was beloved by fans for his relentless work ethic and ability to almost always be around the action. And he has the rings to show for it.

Gouveia was part of Washington's Super Bowl XXII and XXVI championship teams. In Super Bowl XXVI, his crucial interception set up a touchdown that iced the game against the Buffalo Bills, and he managed three picks in each of their three playoff victories during their memorable 1991 championship run.

His 1992 and 1993 seasons were arguably his most productive, racking up 340 tackles. Gouveia lasted just three games in 1994 before injuries took hold, and he left to join the Philadelphia Eagles.

A sad end to an outstanding stint in Washington.

17. Brad Dusek, LB

Brad Dusek wasn't the biggest linebacker to ever grace the league. But he had a knack for playing the position well, with turnovers being his biggest strength.

During eight highly productive seasons in Washington, Dusek recovered 16 fumbles and intercepted four passes, matching his production with his longevity. He saw time with both George Allen and later with Joe Gibbs, becoming a trusted player for both legendary coaches.

Unfortunately for Dusek, his time in Washington came before the team started winning championships again. That said, he was as dependable as they come, and he was unfortunate not to secure Pro Bowl honors throughout his career.

16. Bill Brundige, DL

Washington spent a second-round pick on defensive lineman Bill Brundige, so expectations were high. He proved his value, playing all 107 of his career games with the club and racking up 49.5 sacks along the way.

Brundige was a prominent and feared figure along Washington's defensive front during the George Allen era. He was integral to the team reaching Super Bowl VII and even managed to block a field goal that eventually led to their only touchdown in the contest.

While bigger names lined up in the trenches during some of the greatest days in Washington franchise history, Brundige was supremely talented in his own right.

15-10

15. Rich Milot, LB

Another Washington football lifer, linebacker Rich Milot played 121 games for the club over nine years and was a thumping presence at the defensive second level.

Milot was the definition of a do-it-all linebacker, arguably way ahead of his time. He recorded 13 interceptions and 20.5 sacks throughout his career, becoming a key cog in two championship teams and three Super Bowl appearances.

Even though Milot's contribution was overshadowed by more celebrated, high-profile defensive teammates, he was a legitimate glue guy that every contending team needs. Washington was fortunate to have the seventh-round pick who became a tremendous player.

14. Terry Hermeling, OL/DL

One of the greatest undrafted success stories in Washington history, Terry Hermeling emerged from obscurity to play 120 regular-season games for the club.

A bruising, versatile lineman who started at end before moving to the offensive line, Hermeling blocked for both Larry Brown and John Riggins, helping carve out an identity that still stands strong in the team's culture today.

The Nevada product started in Super Bowl VII, switching between tackle and guard throughout his career and doing whatever it took to help the team during a successful period. Hermeling was named to Washington's 80 Greatest in recognition of his superb efforts.

13. Harold McLinton, LB

Harold McLinton was a mainstay in Washington for a decade, playing 127 games and making a significant contribution with a unique blend of violence and speed, typical of the linebackers the franchise relied on during this era.

McLinton held a starting berth throughout much of his career. He played a critical role on Washington's 1972 NFL championship team, which wasn't bad at all for a sixth-round selection from Southern.

When fans talk about the greatest linebackers in team history, there are plenty to choose from. Though McLinton gets somewhat overlooked, he most definitely deserves to be in the conversation.

12. Mike Bass, CB

A 12th-round pick of the Green Bay Packers who was quickly cast aside by the franchise and then the Detroit Lions, defensive back Mike Bass found a home in Washington. This stable environment was what he needed, and it didn't take long for him to excel.

Bass recorded an impressive 30 interceptions during his seven seasons in Washington. Though he never made the Pro Bowl, he earned second-team All-Pro honors in 1974, showing how highly regarded he was in league circles.

He holds the distinction of scoring Washington's only touchdown in Super Bowl VII, returning Garo Yepremian's errant throw 49 yards to find the end zone. That was his crowning moment, and Bass was inducted into the Ring of Fame in 2022.

11. Jon Jansen, OT

Another player who didn't earn Pro Bowl recognition but made second-team All-Pro, offensive tackle Jon Jansen was a powerful, athletic bruiser who could stonewall you in a heartbeat.

Jansen had the size and length to make things extremely difficult. Washington spent a second-round pick on him after a standout college career at Michigan, and he did not disappoint, playing 126 regular-season contests and starting 80 consecutive games.

His real strength was run blocking. Jansen was among the league's best at this, plowing the road for running back Clinton Portis to break Washington's single-season franchise record for rushing yards in 2005.

Aside from one injury-hit campaign in 2007, Jansen was the model of stability in Washington.

10-5

10. Ed Simmons, DL

A member of the legendary Hogs who spent his entire 11-year career in Washington, Ed Simmons embodied everything good about the franchise during that time. He was part of two championship teams, and whether at tackle or guard, few got the better of him.

Simmons contributed to the Super Bowls, of course. But he also provided much-needed stability during the transitional period that followed. He stayed loyal to the club when it might have been easier to move elsewhere, which speaks to the kind of player and person he was.

Aside from some injury problems, Simmons was an iron-man presence in the trenches. He may not have made a Pro Bowl, but he did receive the alumni association's offensive player of the year honor in 1996, which was his penultimate season in D.C.

9. Raleigh McKenzie, OL

Raleigh McKenzie was the definition of a draft steal. Selected in the 11th round in 1985, the formidable offensive lineman quickly developed into a talented blocker during his decade-long stint with the organization.

McKenzie was a versatile option who could play anywhere. As anyone who's played the game will tell you, switching from one offensive line spot to another is difficult, but he was exceptional at it.

He played a role in Washington's Super Bowl XXII and XXVI triumphs, and he also helped protect quarterback Mark Rypien, who was sacked just seven times during the 1991 campaign.

He later left the club, spending time with the Philadelphia Eagles, Green Bay Packers, and San Diego Chargers before retiring after the 2000 season.

8. Darryl Grant, OL/DL

Darrly Grant was originally drafted as an offensive lineman. Washington quickly switched gears, turning him loose in the defensive trenches. It was a massive gamble at the time, but it had the best possible impact on his career.

Grant won two Super Bowls in Washington, providing stout run-stopping while also flashing eye-catching pass-rushing ability en route to 27 career sacks. He started 109 games for the franchise, and one memorable moment is something fans of a certain age haven't forgotten in a hurry.

Of course, this was Grant pick-six against the Dallas Cowboys in the 1982 NFC Championship Game. It was one of the most surprising plays in team history, and it helped Washington reach Super Bowl VII.

The ninth-round pick left Washington for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 1991, but he played just two games before retiring.

7. Neal Olkewicz, LB

Another undrafted gem who cemented his place in Washington franchise history, Neal Olkewicz played all 150 regular-season games for the team that took a chance on him.

Olkewicz was relentless. He left his mark on almost every tackle, setting the tone on star-studded defenses and helping secure two Super Bowl rings during his time with the organization.

One of those — Super Bowl XVII — saw Olkewicz take the field on his birthday, giving the occasion an emotional feel that did not go unnoticed. There was nothing particularly flashy about his play; he was just in the right place at the right time, and the stars aligned to give him a superb career in Washington.

6. Ricky Sanders, WR

One of the best wide receivers of his time and part of Washington's prolific trio alongside Art Monk and Gary Clark, it remains puzzling that Ricky Sanders didn't earn a Pro Bowl selection during his standout career.

Perhaps playing alongside Monk and Clark led to his omission from individual honors. There is just no telling for sure, but there is no denying the impact Sanders had during his career in Washington.

Sanders was electrifying, winning two championships in D.C. as "The Posse" ran riot over almost everyone unfortunate enough to be in their path. And his crowning glory came in Super Bowl XXII.

The wideout was sensational on the biggest stage, securing nine catches for 193 receiving yards and two touchdowns as Washington beat the Denver Broncos. Sanders' contribution will be remembered through the ages, and it was unfortunate that injuries ended his time with the club.

5-1

5. Doug Williams, QB

Most of the players in this list played in Washington for longer. Almost none had the same cultural impact as quarterback Doug Williams did during his time in D.C.

Williams was a barrier-breaker in every sense, becoming the first black quarterback to start and win a Super Bowl when Washington beat the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XXII. He was incredible, throwing for 340 passing yards and winning Super Bowl MVP in a resounding 42-10 victory.

All four of Williams' touchdown passes came in the third quarter, which remains one of the finest accomplishments in Super Bowl history. Things fizzled out quickly after that, but the signal-caller remains part of the setup today.

Williams holds a front-office position while his son, D.J. Williams, is the Commanders' quarterbacks coach. The legacy lives on.

4. Brig Owens, DB

One of the greatest in-division trades Washington ever made was acquiring Brig Owens from the Dallas Cowboys. At the time, he called it "the best thing that ever happened to me – it allowed for a new beginning."

And he made the Cowboys pay for their lack of judgment.

The gifted defensive back is in the Ring of Fame, having spent 12 seasons in Washington and emerging as a genuine ballhawk at defensive back. His eight interceptions in 1968 are the stuff of legend, and he was a focal point of the team that reached Super Bowl VII.

Owens also recorded an interception in that game, picking off a pass from Bob Griese. A true pioneer who deserved a Pro Bowl honor.

3. Don Warren, TE

Widely regarded as one of the best blocking tight ends of all time, Don Warren was a cornerstone of Joe Gibbs' dynasty in Washington. When the head coach switched his offense to a power-run scheme that needed two tight ends, he flourished, but he was also an underrated pass-catcher when his number was called.

Warren accumulated three championships and four Super Bowl appearances during his 14-year career in Washington. He played almost 200 regular-season games for the club (193), and his elite-level blocking made him an honorary member of the Hogs as a full-blown mauler who could melt your facemask in a hurry.

He was the perfect player for Gibbs' style of play. And his place in Washington history is firmly secure.

2. George Starke, OT

George Starke was affectionately known as the "Head Hog," the leader of one of the most dominant groups of offensive linemen ever to take the field in the NFL. He was a leader of men who never backed down an inch, playing 12 seasons in Washington and helping the organization secure its first-ever Super Bowl on the back of bruising backfield force John Riggins.

Starke was a brick wall of a human. An 11th-round afterthought who had no real hope of carving out a career for himself, he was the man Joe Gibbs and Joe Bugel built the Hogs around. And there haven't been many right tackles in Washington since who have come close to reaching this standard.

Money has changed. The game has changed. But one has to wonder how much money Starke would command in today's NFL as a complete edge protector with a ruthless streak that endeared him to an entire community.

1. Monte Coleman, LB

A rags-to-riches linebacker who defied the odds, Monte Coleman's longevity and accomplishments put him at the top of the list of best players who never made a Pro Bowl.

The 11th-round linebacker stuck around for an incredible 16 seasons in Washington, becoming a trusted ally of Joe Gibbs and someone the head coach never really considered replacing, even in his advancing years.

Coleman won three Super Bowls. He was an exceptional contributor on defense and special teams. His 10.5 sacks from the second level in 1984 were more than enough for a Pro Bowl appearance, but it wasn't to be.

He may have only started around 30 percent of games for Washington, but his impact on the Gibbs championship teams cannot be overstated.

Add us as a preferred source on Google