Marty Hurney would not be the best option for Redskins GM

Hurney could still work, but there are better options out there

It’s still possible that Hurney could work for the Redskins. As we’ve seen in recent offseason, he has improved and refined his tactics, especially in free agency. If that continues in 2020, that could wash away the concerns of the past and make him a better candidate.

His relationship with Rivera would also be a plus. The two men could work well together to create harmony between the coaching staff and front office, and that would be a plus.

All that said, the simple fact remains that there are better options out there for the Redskins to target. There are a number of executives that are available with a more impressive track record than Hurney. Former Texans GM Rick Smith, who the team reportedly interviewed before hiring Rivera, is one of them. So is Nick Caserio, whose contract in New England expires this offseason.

And let’s not dismiss the idea of giving guys like Doug Williams and Kyle Smith promotions to continue the fine work they’ve done with the draft in recent seasons. Even if Eric Schaffer is leaving the team in May, as reports have suggested, Williams and Smith should be kept around to keep things running smoothly. Perhaps Hurney would consider doing that, but if not, that could hurt the ‘Skins more than it helps them.

Rivera bringing over a lot of his guys from Carolina has been fine so far. In fact, it’s been a welcome sight, as it signifies who is really calling the shots for the Redskins.

But Hurney’s resume isn’t flawless. And while he is an upgrade over Bruce Allen, especially in terms of culture and connectivity, his inconsistency is concerning.

Perhaps my tune will change if the Panthers continue to show restraint by making calculated signings in free agency and have another solid draft. But for now, I don’t see Hurney as a great fit, as his previous weaknesses align dangerously with some of the weaknesses the Redskins have exhibited under Daniel Snyder’s watch.