Predicting the likely winners of each Redskins position battle

Quarterback: Case Keenum

The quarterback battle ended up not being much of a contest. Both quarterbacks had their ups and downs, but it was Case Keenum who proved to be the most consistent option and thus, won the starting job.

Though rookie first-round pick Dwayne Haskins showed some upside and growth during his three preseason games so far, he simply didn’t do enough to overtake Keenum. He had some nice throws, but the first game of the preseason showcased that he wasn’t quite ready for the limelight. And while he improved substantially in the next two games, Keenum was steady throughout.

Keenum had what was likely his best outing of the preseason on Thursday night. Getting extensive work with the starters, Keenum was able to connect on some nice passes, including one to Cam Sims where he fit the ball into a tight window and hit his receiver in stride, and helped move the team downfield quickly on the first play of the game. He did have one turnover, an interception that was later called a fumble, but aside from that play, he showed good pocket poise and was able to get rid of the ball at the proper times during the contest.

For the Redskins, Keenum represents the safe option at quarterback. And that’s what Jay Gruden needed to go with, as he has his job on the line. Keenum can manage an efficient offensive attack, avoid turnovers, and make downfield plays. And throughout the preseason, he has showed off nice arm strength, so he should be able to make some nice passes into tight areas and make plays downfield. That was something that the team lacked a bit with Alex Smith at the helm last year.

Now, the only question surrounding Keenum will be, how long will he last as the starter? The Redskins are desperate to win and they have a difficult schedule out of the gate against the Eagles, Cowboys, Bears, Giants, and Patriots. If Keenum can keep them afloat in those contests and emerge with either a 2-3 or 3-2 record, that will give him a chance to stake his claim for the starting job for the rest of the season.

However, Keenum’s margin for error won’t be big. Gruden is coaching for his job and could be forced to make a desperation move if the veteran doesn’t produce early on. This battle will likely continue into the season, but for the time being, Keenum appears to be well ahead.